Give and receive reviews
After a transaction, you can rate the other person with one of three smileys: Good, Okay, or Bad. These ratings determine the satisfaction level that other users see on your profile and listings: TOP, OK, or NOT GREAT. Here you can find out when you can leave a rating, where to find it, and how we calculate your satisfaction level.
When you can leave a review
You can leave a review for anyone you’ve traded with through Gunfinder chat. To do so, you must have both sent each other at least three messages, and the conversation must be at least one day old. If the item is already marked as sold or you’ve started an instant purchase, you can leave a review right away. A dealer’s automatic replies don’t count. The Leave a review button then appears at the top of the conversation next to your trading partner’s name. It stays subtle while you’re still negotiating: a brief exchange without a trade isn’t grounds for a review, and no one should leave a review before the trade is complete.
When a trade seems complete, we’ll remind you to leave a review. This happens when the item is marked as sold or deleted, when your trading partner has already reviewed you, or when a day has passed since the last message. A card asking about your experience then appears at the end of the conversation, and the conversation is marked Leave a review in your message list. If you keep chatting afterward, the card disappears until things quiet down. The button at the top stays either way, so you can decide when to leave a review.
You can leave a review up to 90 days after the last message. After that, too much time has passed to describe the experience fairly, and the button and card disappear.
How to leave a rating
- Open the conversation with the other party.
- Click Rate at the top or use the card at the end of the conversation.
- Choose a smiley: Good, Okay or Bad.
Clicking a smiley saves your rating immediately. You can leave exactly one rating per conversation, and you can't change it afterward. Be objective: How were the communication, transaction and condition of the item?
Where reviews appear and how we calculate them
We don’t show individual reviews or who left them. Instead, we show a satisfaction rating for your entire profile: TOP, OK or NOT GREAT, with a matching smiley. We also show the number of reviews so you can judge how reliable the rating is. You can see the satisfaction rating on profiles, listings and auctions, and on the dealer page.
- The satisfaction rating appears after three reviews. Before that, we only show how many reviews someone has.
- It’s based on the share of reviews rated Good: three-quarters or more means TOP, half or more means OK, and less than half means NOT GREAT. Okay counts neither for nor against.
- Reviews from the last 24 months count. If someone has received fewer than three reviews during that time, we use all their reviews to date.
- Reviews as a seller and as a buyer are combined in the satisfaction rating.
So one bad review won’t immediately turn a TOP rating into NOT GREAT, and anyone who receives a review can’t see who left it. Reviews can’t be deleted or changed, even on request.
Get good reviews yourself
- Reply promptly and politely via Gunfinder chat.
- Describe your items honestly and completely, including signs of wear.
- Stick to agreements on payment and shipping.
- Leave a review after every transaction. If you leave a review, you’ll usually get one too.
For serious issues: don't just leave a bad review—report it
If a user really stands out for the wrong reasons or you suspect fraud, don't just leave a bad review—flag their profile for us so we can investigate. Find out how to report users and listings in Stay safe on Gunfinder.